TallowTallow
Tallow Research

Heinz ketchup has corn syrup in the US and sugar in the UK: what differs, and the white pills video

US Heinz uses corn syrup, the UK bottle uses sugar, and nobody has named the white lumps in the viral video. What is confirmed, what the studies show, and which bottle scores best.

Emily Harper

A glass jar of red tomato sauce topped with herbs beside two cherry tomatoes on a dark surface scattered with spices.

A TikTok of a mom pulling white, pill-shaped lumps out of a Walmart bottle of Heinz ketchup keeps getting passed around, and the comments are full of two questions: what were those things, and why does American Heinz keep getting compared to the version sold in Britain? Short answers: nobody has publicly identified the lumps, and the two bottles really are sweetened differently. Here is what is confirmed, what is not, and how to pick a bottle.

The white "pills" video: what is known

The clip comes from a TikTok posted Oct. 22, 2023 by Laci Jackson (@journey_jacksons), per Distractify's write-up. She said she bought the bottle at Walmart and noticed the pieces while making her daughter a corn dog. They looked uniform in shape, color and size, and when she cut one open it smelled of tomato.

What came after:

  • Commenters' theories: the most common guess was beans, since Heinz also makes baked beans. Others noted that real pills would likely have dissolved in something as acidic as ketchup. A few guessed insect eggs.
  • Heinz's response: an automated reply, shown in a follow-up video, said the company has "stringent and thorough inspections" of ingredients and packing supplies.
  • Walmart's response: it said it would contact Heinz and offered a replacement bottle.
  • What is missing: we could not find a lab result or a public statement from Heinz saying what the pieces were. Every explanation above is a guess, so treat "beans" as a theory, not a finding.

If you open a bottle and find something that should not be there, keep the bottle and the lot code, take photos, and report it to the retailer and the maker. The FDA takes consumer complaints on food products too.

The part that is confirmed: US and European Heinz use different sweeteners

The ingredient list on Heinz's own US product page reads: tomato concentrate from red ripe tomatoes, distilled vinegar, high fructose corn syrup, corn syrup, salt, spice, onion powder, natural flavoring.

The British version is reported as tomatoes, spirit vinegar, sugar, salt, spice and herb extracts and spice, per TruthOrFiction and Is It Banned In Europe. The European bottle we have on Tallow lists the same sugar-based recipe.

US bottleUK and European bottle
SweetenerHigh fructose corn syrup, corn syrupSugar
VinegarDistilled vinegarSpirit vinegar
Onion powderYesNot listed
Flavoring"Natural flavoring""Spice and herb extracts"
Sugars per 100 g (Tallow listing)23 g22.8 g

Look at the last row. The sugar content is nearly the same. The difference is which sweetener supplies it, and the reason the sources give is mostly money: US corn is cheap and abundant, while US sugar tariffs and quotas keep cane and beet sugar pricier. High fructose corn syrup is not banned in the UK. It is just rarely used there, where it is called glucose-fructose syrup.

Is the corn syrup version worse for you?

This is where the viral posts overreach. A 2022 meta-analysis in Frontiers in Nutrition pooled four trials (767 participants) and found no significant difference between high fructose corn syrup and sucrose for body weight, waist circumference, blood pressure, fasting glucose or blood lipids. It did find slightly higher C-reactive protein, an inflammation marker, with high fructose corn syrup, and the authors caution that the studies were short.

The fair reading: the sweetener swap is not proof that one bottle is dangerous and the other is safe. Total added sugar is the bigger lever. A tablespoon of either bottle is a small amount, but ketchup tends to get used in volume, especially on kids' plates.

Is the US bottle GMO?

Corn syrup and high fructose corn syrup come from corn. USDA's Economic Research Service says about 92% of US corn acres are planted with herbicide-tolerant seed, and 87% with insect-resistant (Bt) seed. Most US corn, in other words, is genetically engineered.

That does not automatically put a "bioengineered" line on the bottle. USDA's own consumer material gives some sugars and oils as examples of highly refined ingredients that may not need the disclosure, because modified genetic material may no longer be detectable. A federal appeals court ruled against that exemption in October 2025, and a district court later set January 1, 2028 as the effective date for vacating it. We walk through the rule, the exemptions and the court timeline in our explainer on what "bioengineered" means on a label. Until then, an absent label is not the same as a non-GMO guarantee. We did not see a bioengineered disclosure in Heinz's online ingredient listing, and we have not inspected a physical bottle, so check the label for a symbol or scan code.

The lawsuit people tie to Heinz

Kraft Heinz is the first company named in a December 2025 suit by the City of San Francisco against ten makers of ultra-processed foods, filed in San Francisco Superior Court. The city attorney's release alleges the companies' marketing violates California's Unfair Competition Law and public nuisance law, and it draws a comparison to the tobacco industry, noting that Philip Morris owned Kraft and that a Kraft promotion in the 1990s aimed to reach about 95% of US kids aged 6 to 12. The case was sent back to state court in April 2026, a ruling about where it is heard, not about who is right. These are allegations, and the release does not describe ketchup specifically.

How to pick a ketchup

Here is what each Heinz option lists and how it scores on Tallow.

Heinz's own listing for Simply Heinz reads tomato concentrate, distilled vinegar, cane sugar, salt, onion powder, spice and natural flavoring. The organic bottle lands lower because an independent lab test on Tallow flagged cadmium in it, which is the kind of thing an ingredient list alone cannot show.

Where Tallow fits

You should not need a chemistry degree and a cross-Atlantic comparison chart to choose a condiment. When you scan a ketchup bottle with Tallow, you get the ingredient list scored from 0 to 100, with the corn syrups, "natural flavoring" and processing level broken out, plus lab results where an independent lab has tested the product and cleaner swaps from the same shelf. The Heinz bottle with corn syrup scores 0 and the sugar-sweetened ones score much higher, and you see why before it reaches the table. Scan your ketchup on Tallow before your next cookout.

This post compares ingredient lists and describes a lawsuit's allegations. It does not say any ketchup is unsafe. The contents of the 2023 video's bottle were never publicly identified. Tallow scores reflect our scoring method, not a safety finding. Sources: Heinz US ketchup, Simply Heinz, Heinz organic ketchup, Distractify, TruthOrFiction, Is It Banned In Europe, Frontiers in Nutrition meta-analysis, USDA ERS, San Francisco City Attorney, Courthouse News.