TallowTallow
Tallow Research

Your concealer may list a Prop 65 carcinogen: what DEA is and what the FDA says

California Prop 65 notices name diethanolamine (DEA) in concealers from Tower 28, ILIA and others. What DEA is, what the FDA and EU say, and the PFAS question.

Emily Harper

Makeup brushes, lipstick, mascara and compacts arranged on a beige background.

Open the ingredient list on your concealer and look for words ending in "DEA." Since 2024, a run of California Prop 65 notices has named diethanolamine (DEA) in concealers, foundations, and mascaras, including brands that market themselves as clean (Tower 28, ILIA).

This post covers what those notices actually say, what the FDA says in response, and what the separate PFAS question in makeup looks like. A notice is an allegation, not a finding, so we are keeping the two apart.

The quick version

  • DEA has been on California's Prop 65 list of chemicals known to cause cancer since 2012. The 2024 notices cite a June 22, 2012 listing date, although one concealer notice gives a different date, so treat the exact day as unconfirmed.
  • The notices were filed by the Initiative for Safer Cosmetics through the Cliffwood Law Firm. They allege shoppers were exposed through skin absorption without a warning.
  • The FDA says an animal study found cancer links, but that it did not establish a link in humans, and it sees no reason for consumers to be alarmed.
  • Separately, a 2021 Notre Dame study found fluorine, a marker for PFAS, in about half of the cosmetics it screened.

What the Prop 65 notices say

California's attorney general publishes every 60-day notice of intent to sue. Under Prop 65, a business that sells a product exposing people to a listed chemical has to give a clear warning, and the notice is the step before a lawsuit can be filed.

We could confirm these concealer notices on the state's public database:

BrandConcealer namedDate filed
Tower 28Swipe All-Over Hydrating Serum ConcealerJune 10, 2024
ILIATrue Skin Serum Concealer (Birch)June 23, 2024
MAKEUP BY MARIOSurrealSkin Awakening Concealer2024 (filed more than once)
Glo Skin BeautyLuminous Brightening ConcealerJune 30, 2024
KosasRevealer Super Creamy + Brightening ConcealerDecember 15, 2024

Notices also name concealers from Pat McGrath, Jane Iredale, Flower Beauty and others, and some of the same filings cover mascara and other products. The database shows allegations only. A product appearing there does not mean a court found a violation, and we did not find a ruling for any of them. At least one related notice, naming Rose Inc, was later withdrawn.

Why DEA is on the list

DEA is used in cosmetics to adjust pH and help oil and water mix. It can also be a leftover in ingredients made from it, such as cocamide DEA and lauramide DEA.

The cancer concern traces to the National Toxicology Program, which ran skin-application studies in rodents in the late 1990s. The FDA's summary is that the study found an association between DEA and related ingredients and cancer in lab animals, tied to possible residual DEA in the related ingredients (FDA). The same page says the study did not establish a link between DEA and cancer risk in people, that these ingredients are used much less often than when the study was done, and that there is no reason for consumers to be alarmed.

That is a real disagreement between regulators, and it is worth saying plainly. California lists DEA as a carcinogen. The FDA treats the evidence as animal data without proven human risk.

What Europe does

The EU takes the cautious side. A European Medicines Agency opinion describes secondary alkanolamines, the chemical family DEA belongs to, as a total ban in cosmetics under Annex II of Regulation 1223/2009 (EMA opinion). Secondary amines can react with other ingredients to form nitrosamines, which is the usual reason given for the restriction. We could not confirm the current legal status of DEA-derived ingredients such as cocamide DEA, so check the EU's CosIng database before relying on that point.

The separate PFAS question

DEA is not the only concern people raise about makeup. In 2021, researchers at the University of Notre Dame screened 231 cosmetics bought in the US and Canada for fluorine, a marker for PFAS. About half had high fluorine readings. Reported figures include 56% of foundations and eye products, 48% of lip products, 47% of mascaras, and 82% of waterproof mascaras (AP via Phys.org).

Twenty-nine of the products were tested further and contained between 4 and 13 specific PFAS, and reports say fewer than 8% listed PFAS on the label (NBC Connecticut). Fluorine is a marker, not a measured PFAS level, which is why the 82% figure is a share of products, not a dose.

We have covered the government side of this before: the FDA's first PFAS-in-cosmetics report and the dismissed Maybelline mascara PFAS lawsuit.

What to do instead

  • Scan for the "DEA" suffix. Cocamide DEA, lauramide DEA and diethanolamine itself are the names to look for in the ingredient list.
  • Treat a Prop 65 notice as a flag, not a verdict. Check the date and the product in the California attorney general's public Prop 65 notice database, then see whether the brand has reformulated.
  • Watch the PFAS words. Anything with "fluoro" or "PTFE" in the name is worth a second look, and waterproof or long-wear formulas were the highest category in the Notre Dame screen.
  • Favor shorter lists. Fewer ingredients means fewer places for a leftover to hide.

How Tallow helps with this

Concealer labels are long and the names are hard to read at the counter. Tallow lets you scan a product or search it and see the ingredients flagged in plain language, so you can check a name like cocamide DEA before it goes on your face.

Eat clean. Drink clean.

Sources: California Attorney General Prop 65 notice 2024-02318 and notice 2024-02505; FDA on diethanolamine; EMA opinion; Notre Dame study coverage via AP/Phys.org (Environmental Science & Technology Letters, June 2021). Prop 65 notices are allegations, not findings. This is not medical advice.