The FDA found 51 forever chemicals in 1,744 cosmetics and could not say if they are safe
The FDA's first PFAS-in-cosmetics report counted 51 PFAS in 1,744 products and says safety data is incomplete. What it covers, what it misses, and the talc rule it pulled.
Emily Harper
In December 2025, the FDA published its first-ever report on PFAS in cosmetics. It found that 51 different "forever chemicals" are intentionally added to 1,744 cosmetic formulations sold in the US. Then it said, in its own words, that "toxicological data for a majority of these PFAS are incomplete or unavailable." Ten months later, nothing on the front of your makeup bag tells you which products those are.
Here is what the report actually says, what it does not say, and the two other gaps in cosmetics oversight that came out of the same stretch of time.
What the FDA report found
The report was required by the 2022 cosmetics law (MoCRA), and the FDA published it on December 29, 2025. The key numbers:
- 51 PFAS are intentionally used in 1,744 cosmetic formulations, based on the product listing data companies are now required to submit.
- The FDA evaluated the 25 most frequently used PFAS, which account for about 96% of intentional PFAS additions.
- Of those 25, 5 looked like low safety concerns under their intended use, 1 was flagged as a potential concern with significant uncertainty, and the rest did not have enough data to reach a conclusion.
A law firm summary of the report adds the detail that the one flagged ingredient was perfluorohexylethyl triethoxysilane in body lotion, that the remaining 19 had insufficient data, and that 56% of the PFAS-containing products fall in five categories: eye shadow, face and neck leave-on products, eyeliner, face powder and foundation.
What the report does not say
Two limits matter before anyone draws a conclusion from those numbers.
- It only counts PFAS that companies chose to add. The FDA's announcement says the report focuses on intentionally added PFAS, not contaminants. A product can carry PFAS that never appears on a listing.
- "Insufficient data" is not "safe." The FDA's own wording points to missing data on use levels, skin absorption and toxicity. That is a gap in the evidence, not a clean bill of health, and not proof of harm either.
The same law firm summary notes that PFAS-containing products were about 0.41% of all registered cosmetic products as of August 2024. So this is a small share of the market, but the share is concentrated in the products people wear on their eyes and faces.
Why independent testing found more than listings do
The FDA report relies on what companies disclose. An earlier independent study did the opposite: it measured the products. Researchers at Notre Dame screened more than 200 cosmetics for total fluorine, a marker for PFAS, and found high levels in 56% of foundations and eye products, 48% of lip products and 47% of mascaras. Of 29 products tested further for specific compounds, only one listed PFAS on its label.
Total fluorine is a marker, not proof of a specific compound, and the study was published in 2021. But it is the reason "check the ingredient list" is incomplete advice. We covered the lawsuit side of that research in our earlier post on makeup lawsuits and the mascara case that was dismissed in this breakdown.
A PFAS penalty tied to a named makeup ingredient
Canada gave a concrete example of what the ingredient looks like in practice. On January 13, 2026, Estee Lauder Cosmetics Ltd. was fined $750,000 in the Ontario Court of Justice after pleading guilty to two counts under the Canadian Environmental Protection Act.
The substance was perfluorononyl dimethicone, a PFAS found in eyeliner. Inspectors found it in May 2023, and the charges were failing to notify the government of a significant new activity and failing to comply with a June 2023 compliance order. This was a notification and compliance case, not a ruling that the eyeliner harmed anyone. But it gives you a real ingredient name to look for. Anything with "fluoro" or "perfluoro" in the name is worth a closer look.
The talc gap
The other half of the "who checks your makeup" question is talc. In July 2024 the WHO's cancer agency classified talc as "probably carcinogenic to humans" (Group 2A), noting that asbestos has been reported as a contaminant in some talc ores and products.
The FDA had proposed a rule in December 2024 that would have required talc-containing cosmetics to be tested for asbestos. On November 28, 2025, the agency withdrew that proposal, citing "scientific, technical, and legal complexities" raised in public comments. It said it would reconsider the approach and propose a new rule. We found no replacement rule published in our research, so there is still no federal standard testing method for asbestos in cosmetic talc.
One more category: hair straighteners
Outside makeup, one of the strongest human datasets in this space comes from hair products. The NIH Sister Study followed 33,947 women for an average of 10.9 years. Frequent use of hair straighteners (more than 4 times in the prior year) was linked to a hazard ratio of 2.55 for uterine cancer. The predicted risk by age 70 was about 4.05% for frequent users versus 1.64% for never users.
The authors were open about the limits: brands and ingredients were not collected, so the specific chemicals were not identified, and exposure was self-reported for a single year. It shows an association worth knowing about, not which product is responsible.
What to do with this
- Read the label for "fluoro" and "perfluoro" names, and treat "waterproof" and "long-wear" as a reason to look closer.
- Remember what a missing warning means. The FDA has no premarket approval for cosmetics, so "not recalled" is not the same as "reviewed."
- Check the product, not the brand. A company can have one cleaner line and one that is not.
Scan before you buy
Everything above comes down to one problem: the label often does not tell you enough, and regulators are still collecting data. Tallow reads the ingredient list for you and scores the product. For example, Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Waterproof mascara on Tallow currently scores 15 out of 100.
Scan your own makeup with Tallow before the next purchase, and use the score to find a cleaner swap in the same category.
Figures in this post come from the FDA, Environment and Climate Change Canada, the WHO's cancer agency, and peer-reviewed or university-published research linked above, current as of the time of writing. This is not medical or legal advice.