TallowTallow
Tallow Research

The bread brands people say to avoid tested cleanest for weed killer. Here's what the label says instead

Florida's bread test found glyphosate in Wonder and Sara Lee Honey Wheat but none in Sara Lee Artesano or Pepperidge Farm. Here is what that does and does not tell you.

Emily Harper

Loaves of crusty bread stacked on a bakery shelf.

If you saw the bread-and-weed-killer story in February, you probably came away with a short list of brands to avoid. Look at the lab table again and that list does not hold up. The loaves that tested cleanest are not the ones the internet told you to worry about, and two loaves with no glyphosate detected still score near zero on Tallow for reasons that have nothing to do with the test.

This is a follow-up to our deep dive on organic bread and glyphosate, which covers what the USDA Organic seal does and does not promise. This post asks a different question: what does the test actually tell you about the brand on the bag, and what does it leave out?

The result everyone skipped

Florida's Department of Health tested eight loaves under its Healthy Florida First initiative. The results are posted publicly, and the state's own announcement went out in February 2026.

LoafGlyphosateAgainst EWG's 160 ppb benchmark
Sara Lee Honey Wheat191.04 ppbOver
Nature's Own Butter Bread190.23 ppbOver
Wonder Classic White173.19 ppbOver
Nature's Own Perfectly Crafted White132.34 ppbUnder
Dave's Killer Bread White Done Right11.85 ppbUnder
Dave's Killer Bread 21 Whole Grains and Seeds10.38 ppbUnder
Sara Lee Artesano WhiteNon-detectUnder
Pepperidge Farm Farmhouse Hearty WhiteNon-detectUnder

The 160 ppb figure is the Environmental Working Group's children's health benchmark, not a legal limit. The EPA's tolerance for glyphosate on oats, for comparison, is 30,000 ppb, so no loaf in this table is anywhere near a federal violation. Against the stricter benchmark, three loaves are over and five are under.

Two things stand out. First, the highest and lowest results sit inside one company. Wonder, Nature's Own and Dave's Killer Bread are all owned by Flowers Foods, and the gap between Nature's Own Butter Bread (190.23 ppb) and Dave's Killer Bread 21 Whole Grains (10.38 ppb) is about 18 times. That is not a brand story. It is a flour story, and the bag does not tell you which flour you got.

Second, the two loaves that came back non-detect, Sara Lee Artesano and Pepperidge Farm Farmhouse Hearty White, are exactly the kind of mass-market white bread that "avoid the supermarket loaf" advice lumps in with the worst ones. (Sara Lee is part of Bimbo Bakeries USA, a different company from Flowers.) One result is one loaf on one day, so we would not crown a winner from it. We also would not blame a brand for the company it shares a shelf with.

"Not detected" is not the same as "good"

Here is where the lab result and the label part ways. We checked the two non-detect loaves against what Tallow scores.

  • Pepperidge Farm Farmhouse Hearty White (24 oz) scores 0 on Tallow. The lab data on the listing shows glyphosate not detected, so the points it loses for contaminants come from something else: total ortho-phthalates, measured at 44.6 ppb, with no published safety limit to compare against. The ingredient list adds enriched wheat flour, soybean oil, calcium propionate, soy lecithin and DATEM, and the product is rated ultra-processed.
  • Sara Lee Artesano Bakery Bread scores 5 on Tallow. That listing has no lab data attached and we cannot say it is the exact loaf Florida tested, so we are not claiming the glyphosate result for it. What the label shows is vegetable oil, enriched flour, soy lecithin, cultured wheat flour and grain vinegar, with five ingredients flagged to avoid.

Neither bread is a safety emergency. The point is that "tested clean for one thing" and "a clean ingredient list" are two separate questions, and the first headline only answers the first.

The label problem the lab test cannot see

The three loaves with the highest glyphosate also carry ingredients most shoppers cannot decode.

"Dough conditioners." Wonder Classic White's label, as listed by a grocery retailer, reads "contains one or more of the following" and then names sodium stearoyl lactylate, calcium stearoyl lactylate, mono- and diglycerides, calcium peroxide, calcium iodate, DATEM, ethoxylated mono- and diglycerides, azodicarbonamide and enzymes. "One or more" means the bag does not say which are in your loaf. Calcium peroxide is not accepted everywhere: a review of flour bleaching notes that China prohibited both benzoyl peroxide and calcium peroxide in flour production in 2011. We could not confirm how the EU treats calcium peroxide from a primary source, so we are leaving that comparison out.

Calcium propionate. It is a mold inhibitor, and it is on the ingredient lists Tallow has for Wonder, Sara Lee Honey Wheat and Pepperidge Farm. The research is early but worth knowing. In a Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health study published in 2019, 14 healthy people ate a meal containing 1 gram of propionate in a double-blinded, placebo-controlled design. Glucagon, norepinephrine and FABP4 rose, and insulin action was impaired. Mice given a dose equivalent to what humans typically consume gained significant weight and developed insulin resistance. It was a small trial and it does not show that bread preserved with calcium propionate causes diabetes. It is a reason the question is open, and a reason to want to see the ingredient instead of finding it at the end of a 20-item list.

Why this matters this week

On September 22, 2026, the EPA and HHS signed a memorandum of understanding to jointly review glyphosate science. A working group will look at toxicology, occupational epidemiology, exposure and biomonitoring, and dietary exposure. The target for EPA's updated human health risk assessment is now early 2027, and the agencies confirmed that EPA alone decides whether glyphosate stays on the market. Critics quoted by The New Lede called the move "smoke and mirrors," while a litigation attorney there said it addresses real gaps. Either way, nothing changes on the shelf before 2027.

The caveats

Each Florida result is one loaf from one purchase, and Florida did not publish its full laboratory methodology or limits of detection (we flagged this in our earlier post too). Every number above is a tiny fraction of the legal tolerance. Treat this as a signal about which questions to ask, not a ranking you can shop by.

How to shop this

  1. Ignore the brand, read the loaf. The same company made both the highest and the lowest result in this test.
  2. A short ingredient list beats a clean test. Stone House Rustic Sourdough lists four ingredients and scores 100 on Tallow. izzio Organic San Francisco Style Sourdough lists six and scores 99.
  3. Watch for flavored sandwich bread wearing a sourdough label. Yeast, vinegar or "cultured wheat flour" on the list means added flavor, not a long ferment.
  4. "Contains one or more of the following" is a flag. If the bag will not say which additive is in it, you cannot judge it.

The easier way

Everything above took lab tables, ingredient lists and research papers, and nobody does that in the bread aisle. That is what we built Tallow for. Scan any loaf on Tallow and you get a 0 to 100 score, the lab-measured contaminant numbers where we have them, and every flagged additive on the label. It is how we found out that a loaf with no glyphosate detected can still score 0.

Figures in this post come from the Florida Department of Health's published Healthy Florida First results, the studies and reports linked above, and Tallow product pages as of September 30, 2026. Tallow listings may not match the exact loaf Florida tested. No product described here was recalled or found in violation of a federal limit. This is not medical advice.