Amish butter
100Clean
Ingredients · 2
GoodCautionAvoid,
Healthier swaps
Same shelf, cleaner ingredients
Common questions
Is Amish butter healthy?
Amish butter scores 100/100 on Tallow — our clean band. That number comes from what is on the label: the ingredients, how processed it is, and what it is packaged in. It is not a verdict on your diet — Tallow does not weigh calories, portion size or how often you eat it, so a high score means the ingredients are clean, not that the food is unlimited.
What is in Amish butter?
Amish butter lists 2 ingredients, starting with Cream and Salt. Ingredients are listed in descending order by weight, so the first few make up most of what you are eating.
Does Amish butter contain seed oils?
No. Nothing in Amish butter’s ingredient list matches a seed oil — canola, soybean, corn, cottonseed, grapeseed, sunflower, safflower, rice bran or peanut oil, or an unspecified "vegetable oil".
How processed is Amish butter?
We don’t have a NOVA classification on file for Amish butter yet, so the processing axis scores it neutrally.
How does Amish butter compare to other butter & cream?
At 100/100 Amish butter sits in our top band, among the better butter & cream we have scored.
Is Amish butter organic?
Amish butter is not certified organic in our data.
Has Amish butter been lab tested?
Not yet. No independent lab has published results for Amish butter, so its score is based on its ingredient list, processing and packaging alone.
Full methodology: how we score products.