Steak 'n Shake fries in 100% beef tallow, says its fries and tots are now completely seed-oil free, and the burger is a grass fed grass finished steakburger on a bun they say is now seed-oil free. The seed oil that is left is inside the frozen products: the onion rings and chicken fingers are fried in tallow, but their own published statements still list vegetable oil. Only 4 of 106 components carry a real ingredient statement, so the buns, sauces and cheese sauce are unverified.
Steak 'n Shake publishes its nutrition and allergen data through the EveryBite tool their menu page links to, covering 131 dishes and 106 components, plus a seed-oils page. The tallow component is now attached to 27 dishes: every fry, crinkle-cut and tot item, the onion rings and both chicken finger items. Frying in tallow does not clean the product, though. The Regular Onion Rings still list vegetable oil (soybean and/or canola), the Koch tenders say the breading is set in vegetable oil, and their own seed-oils page only calls the fries and tots seed-oil free. On October 5 they said every bun is seed-oil free and made with Wisconsin butter. The new butter buns are in the tool but list no ingredients, so I took that on their word. Only 4 of 106 components have a real ingredient statement, and all 4 contain additives like phosphates, modified starch or caramel color. The sauces, ranch, cheese sauce, chili and shake syrups are still unverified.




