PopUp Bagels confirmed its bagels are just flour, water, yeast, sugar and salt with no seed oils, baked fresh all day, but it could not share ingredients for the schmears or whitefish salad, so those remain unknown.
PopUp Bagels answered our email quickly. The bagels themselves are about as simple as it gets: flour, water, yeast, sugar and salt, no seed oils, baked fresh in small batches all day. There are no fryers on the menu either. The gap is everything you put on the bagel. They told us they do not have ingredient information for the schmears beyond noting the Monty's vegan scallion schmear is cashew based and made outside, and they did not answer whether the whitefish salad uses mayo. So we scored the menu as some seed oil and some additives to stay cautious until we know more. A plain bagel is a safe pick; ask about the schmear before ordering one.




