TallowTallow

Jeremiah's Italian Ice

187 locations · 1 rating

25/100Avoid

Verified from Tallow research, Sep 8, 2026

Open in Maps

Directions go to the location you picked — 3232 SW 35th Blvd, Gainesville.

What the score is made of

Two things, counted the same: seed oils and artificial ingredients. Nothing else moves the number.

  • Seed oils50
  • Artificial ingredients0

Full methodology: how we score restaurants.

What reviewers said

Tallow research2mo ago

Jeremiah's publishes no ingredient statements, but its own footnotes say the soy mark covers unrefined soybean oil, that all flavors contain a form of corn syrup, and that only four ices are dye free - which implies dye in the rest. Fifteen fruit ices carry no allergen marks at all.

Jeremiah's does not publish ingredient statements - the nutrition PDF is numbers and the allergen sheets are X grids. But their footnotes say more than most. The soy column is footnoted "includes Soy Lecithin and Unrefined Soybean Oil", and 46 of 102 items carry that mark, so soybean oil is in the range somewhere but the column mixes it with lecithin and you cannot tell per item which one you are getting. On additives the telling line is "Lemon, P-Nutty, Coconut, and Pina Colada Ices are Dye Free" - naming four dye-free flavors implies dye in the rest of them. They also state "All flavors contain a form of corn syrup", sulfites show up in 12 items, and the sugar-free line runs on sorbitol, sucralose and acesulfame K. If you want to order around it, 15 of the fruit ices carry no allergen marks at all, and the rule is cup not cone, no sprinkles.

Common questions

What is in Jeremiah's Italian Ice's food?

Tallow checks Jeremiah's Italian Ice on two things: whether it cooks in seed oils, and whether the menu carries artificial ingredients like dyes and preservatives. Both count the same, and each is scored below.

Does Jeremiah's Italian Ice use seed oils?

Sometimes. Jeremiah's Italian Ice scores 50/100 here, so reports are mixed.

Does Jeremiah's Italian Ice use artificial ingredients?

Yes. Jeremiah's Italian Ice scores 0/100 here — a lot of artificial ingredients.

Is Jeremiah's Italian Ice healthy?

Not really — Jeremiah's Italian Ice scores 25/100, a poor score. Tallow rates what a kitchen cooks with, not how many calories are on the plate.

Jeremiah's Italian Ice locations

Showing 40 of 187

  • 3232 SW 35th Blvd, Gainesville — the one you picked
  • 7203 Radio Rd Street Level, Naples
  • 3650 N Federal Hwy, Lighthouse PT
  • 1892 Andorra St Unit C4, Navarre
  • 11586 US Highway 1 Street Level, North Palm Beach
  • 2652 Boiling Springs Rd, Boiling Springs
  • 413 N Alafaya Trl Waterford Lakes Town Center, Orlando
  • 6864 Aloma Ave, Winter Park
  • 1000 Willa Springs Dr, Winter Springs
  • 4355 W Lake Mary Blvd, Lake Mary
  • 877 N Alafaya Trl, Orlando
  • 2491 W State Road 434, Longwood
  • 4750 the Grove Dr, Windermere
  • 853 Blanding Blvd, Orange Park
  • 1024 Lockwood Blvd, Oviedo
  • 3988 W Town Center Blvd, Orlando
  • 825 E Bloomingdale Ave, Brandon
  • 14320 N Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa
  • 9891 San Jose Blvd, Jacksonville
  • 3150 S Orange Ave, Orlando
  • 433 S Orlando Ave, Maitland
  • 9172 Wiles Rd, Coral Springs
  • 80 Golden Days Dr, Casselberry
  • 4051 S Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa
  • 227 Daytona Blvd, Daytona Beach
  • 6536 Old Brick Rd Ste 140, Windermere
  • 2213 Edgewater Dr, Orlando
  • 9971 Tagore Pl Ste 8, Orlando
  • 6017 S Goldenrod Rd, Orlando
  • 2405 Tarpon Bay Blvd, Naples
  • 4050 S Alma School Rd, Chandler
  • 8624 US Highway 301 S, Riverview
  • 2369 S Woodland Blvd, DeLand
  • 7820 Eldorado Pkwy Ste 100, McKinney
  • 9630 Stirling Rd Ste 7-101, Hollywood
  • 162 S Nova Rd, Ormond Beach
  • 902 Saxon Blvd Ste C, Orange City
  • 1002 Bay Ave, Columbus
  • 254 Green Hollow Dr, Temple
  • 2707 E Silver Springs Blvd, Ocala

Rating and reporting happen in the app so submissions can be verified and moderated. Browse more on the restaurant map, or check packaged groceries with the product finder. Own a restaurant that skips seed oils? Get listed as seed-oil-free.