Hat Creek emailed us its sauce ingredient lists: the fryers use beef tallow and the grill uses no fat, but the fries are pre-fried in soybean oil and all five sauces (Hat, Happy, Fry, ranch, honey mustard) contain soybean oil.
Hat Creek answered our email and sent ingredient sheets for its sauces, so this rating rests on their own documents. The good part is real: the fryers use beef tallow and nothing goes on the grill, so the burger patty, grilled chicken and tallow-fried nuggets are clean as cooked. The catch is that the fries are pre-fried in soybean oil before they arrive, and every sauce they sent is soybean-oil based: Hat Sauce and Fry Sauce are built on mayo, Happy Sauce has A-1, and the ranch and honey mustard both list soybean oil. The ranch also has MSG, EDTA and artificial flavor, and the bacon is cured with sodium nitrite. The gluten-free bun has canola oil; the regular bun, queso and shakes were not covered. Best order: a burger or grilled chicken with no sauce and no bacon, or nuggets with no dipping sauce, and skip the fries.