TallowTallow
Graeter's Ice Cream — photo
Graeter's Ice Cream — photo 2
Graeter's Ice Cream — photo 3
Graeter's Ice Cream — photo 4
Graeter's Ice Cream — photo 5

Graeter's Ice Cream

68 locations · 1 rating

50/100Okay
Some premade

Verified from Tallow research, Oct 5, 2026

Open in Maps

Directions go to the location you picked — Cincinnati Zoo, Cincinnati.

What the score is made of

Two things, counted the same: seed oils and artificial ingredients. Nothing else moves the number.

  • Seed oils50
  • Artificial ingredients50

Full methodology: how we score restaurants.

What we know

  • Publishes ingredients: full ingredient list for every flavor, cake and pie (84 items)
  • Artificial dyes: FD&C dyes in 11 items (Cherry Chip, Cotton Candy, Beast Feast, S'mores...)
  • BHA/BHT/TBHQ: TBHQ in Elena's Blueberry Ice Cream Pie

Clean picks

  • Madagascar Vanilla Bean
  • Strawberry
  • Salted Caramel
  • Dutch Milk Chocolate
  • Sorbets

What reviewers said

Tallow research1mo ago

Graeter's publishes full ingredient lists, and its plain flavors like vanilla bean, strawberry and the sorbets are clean, but its signature chocolate chips contain soybean oil, so 49 of 84 items have a seed oil and 26 have artificial flavors, dyes or preservatives.

Graeter's publishes a full ingredient list for every flavor, cake and pie, and we read all 84. The base ice cream is simple: cream, milk, cane sugar and eggs, made in small French Pot batches. The catch is the chocolate chips. They are made with soybean oil, so every chip flavor, including the famous Black Raspberry Chip, has a seed oil. Overall 49 of 84 items do. Cookies and cream flavors use Oreos with canola, the Wheelie cookie sandwiches use soybean and cottonseed shortening, and Butter Pecan's pecans are roasted in cottonseed oil. Additives show up in 26 items, mostly the novelty flavors, cakes and pies: artificial flavor, potassium sorbate, FD&C dyes, a few with sodium benzoate, one pie with TBHQ, and potassium bromate in three Wheelies. The safe picks are the plain flavors: Madagascar Vanilla Bean, Strawberry, Salted Caramel, Dutch Milk Chocolate, the coffees and the sorbets.

Common questions

What is in Graeter's Ice Cream's food?

Tallow checks Graeter's Ice Cream on two things: whether it cooks in seed oils, and whether the menu carries artificial ingredients like dyes and preservatives. Both count the same, and each is scored below.

Does Graeter's Ice Cream use seed oils?

Sometimes. Graeter's Ice Cream scores 50/100 here, so reports are mixed.

Does Graeter's Ice Cream use artificial ingredients?

Sometimes. Graeter's Ice Cream scores 50/100 here, so reports are mixed.

Is Graeter's Ice Cream healthy?

Partly — Graeter's Ice Cream scores 50/100, which is middling. Tallow rates what a kitchen cooks with, not how many calories are on the plate.

Is Graeter's Ice Cream's food made fresh?

Partly. Reports say some of Graeter's Ice Cream's food arrives premade. That's shown as info and doesn't change the score.

Graeter's Ice Cream locations

Showing 40 of 68

  • Cincinnati Zoo, Cincinnati — the one you picked
  • 2136 Bethel Rd, Columbus
  • 654 High St, Worthington
  • 3762 Powell Rd, Powell
  • 2204 Bardstown Rd, Louisville
  • 1 N State St, Westerville
  • 332 Ludlow Ave, Cincinnati
  • 511 Walnut St, Cincinnati
  • 6918 Wooster Pike, Cincinnati
  • 3735 Harrodsburg Rd, Lexington
  • 899 W Galbraith Rd, Cincinnati
  • 2412 Far Hills Ave, Oakwood
  • 2145 Reading Rd, Cincinnati
  • 2282 E Main St, Bexley
  • 2376 Ferguson Rd, Cincinnati
  • 140 Breckenridge Ln, Louisville
  • 2704 Erie Ave, Cincinnati
  • 1500 Cross Creeks Blvd, Pickerington
  • 5076 Natorp Blvd, Mason
  • 6255 Metro Pl, Dublin
  • 1534 W Lane Ave, Columbus
  • 2 N Main St, Centerville
  • 6509 Bardstown Rd, Louisville
  • 2330 N Fairfield Rd, Beavercreek
  • 11511 Princeton Pike, Springdale
  • 301 Buttermilk Pike, Lakeside Park
  • 4009 Broadway, Grove City
  • 325 Romany Rd, Lexington
  • 9356 Colerain Ave, Cincinnati
  • 147 Easton Town Ctr, Easton
  • 4101 Tates Creek Centre Dr, Lexington
  • 8533 Beechmont Ave, Cincinnati
  • 425 Beecher Rd, Gahanna
  • 9430 Brownsboro Rd, Louisville
  • 13817 English Villa Dr, Louisville
  • 4310 Charlestown Rd, New Albany
  • 1409 Grand Ave, Fort Thomas
  • 7651 Cox Ln, West Chester
  • 836 Euclid Ave, Lexington
  • 2939 Terminal Dr, Hebron

Rating and reporting happen in the app so submissions can be verified and moderated. Browse more on the restaurant map, or check packaged groceries with the product finder. Own a restaurant that skips seed oils? Get listed as seed-oil-free.