TallowTallow
Donatos Pizza — photo
Donatos Pizza — photo 2
Donatos Pizza — photo 3
Donatos Pizza — photo 4
Donatos Pizza — photo 5

Donatos Pizza

317 locations · 1 rating

25/100Avoid
Some premade

Verified from the chain's own ingredient document, Sep 5, 2026

Open in Maps

Directions go to the location you picked — 1145 S Tamiami Trl, Sarasota.

What the score is made of

Two things, counted the same: seed oils and artificial ingredients. Nothing else moves the number.

  • Seed oils0
  • Artificial ingredients50

Full methodology: how we score restaurants.

What we know

  • Publishes ingredients: 76 component ingredient statements (July 2026)
  • Gluten-free options: Gluten Free 12 in crust
  • BHA/BHT/TBHQ: BHA and BHT in pepperoni and salami; TBHQ in one item
  • Added MSG: both ranch dressings
  • Nitrites: bacon, ham, pepperoni, salami

What reviewers said

Tallow research2mo ago

Four of Donatos' five pizza doughs contain soybean, palm or canola oil, so seed oil is hard to avoid unless you order the cauliflower crust, and eight of nine dressings are soybean oil based. On additives they are better than most pizza chains, with no high fructose corn syrup anywhere and preservatives confined to the cured meats.

Donatos publishes 76 real component ingredient statements, dated July 2026, and 33 of them name a seed or vegetable oil. What decides this is the dough: four of the five doughs carry soybean, palm or canola, so almost any pizza you order has it. The 10 inch cauliflower crust is the only dough with no added oil of any kind. Eight of the nine dressings are soybean oil based, both ranches on a soybean oil mayonnaise, and the breadsticks use soybean plus sunflower. Additives are lighter than most pizza chains: no high fructose corn syrup anywhere, BHA and BHT in only the three cured meats, TBHQ in one item, MSG in the two ranches, titanium dioxide in one dressing. They do not publish a fryer oil at all despite selling wings, so that is unknown rather than clean.

Common questions

What is in Donatos Pizza's food?

Tallow checks Donatos Pizza on two things: whether it cooks in seed oils, and whether the menu carries artificial ingredients like dyes and preservatives. Both count the same, and each is scored below.

Does Donatos Pizza use seed oils?

Yes. Donatos Pizza scores 0/100 here — reports say it cooks heavily in seed oils.

Does Donatos Pizza use artificial ingredients?

Sometimes. Donatos Pizza scores 50/100 here, so reports are mixed.

Is Donatos Pizza healthy?

Not really — Donatos Pizza scores 25/100, a poor score. Tallow rates what a kitchen cooks with, not how many calories are on the plate.

Is Donatos Pizza's food made fresh?

Partly. Reports say some of Donatos Pizza's food arrives premade. That's shown as info and doesn't change the score.

Donatos Pizza locations

Showing 40 of 317

  • 1145 S Tamiami Trl, Sarasota — the one you picked
  • 1758 Allentown Rd, Lansdale
  • 130 1st Ave NW, Aitkin
  • 2128 Mounds Rd, Anderson
  • 6795 S Cornerstar Way, Aurora
  • 950 Shaw Ave, Clovis
  • Sardis Cmns, Indian Trail
  • 10300 W Sprague Rd, Cleveland
  • 20033 Detroit Rd, Cleveland
  • 4514 Centerplace Dr, Greeley
  • 3601 Murdoch Ave, Parkersburg
  • 21 N Broad St, Fairborn
  • 852 Buenaventura Blvd, Kissimmee
  • 21239 S Ellsworth Loop Rd, Queen Creek
  • 1 N Hawkins Ave, Akron
  • 3420 W Chandler Blvd, Chandler
  • 10214 N Metro Pkwy W, Phoenix
  • 10 Cabela Dr, Garner
  • 46 E Allen St, Castle Rock
  • 11500 Midlothian Tpke, North Chesterfield
  • 11420 Capital Blvd, Wake Forest
  • 200 Mount De Chantal Rd, Wheeling
  • 2215 Arbor Blvd, Moraine
  • 401 NE Northgate Way Spc 430, Seattle
  • 9600 S Eastern Ave, Henderson
  • 5143 Drumcliff Ct, Columbus
  • 2260 Walnut St, Cary
  • 4160 Old Milton Pkwy, Alpharetta
  • 362 S Elm St, Greensboro
  • 316 Beall Ave, Wooster
  • 813 E Main St, Brownsburg
  • 1730 Hilliard Rome Rd, Hilliard
  • 2692 Madison Rd, Cincinnati
  • 363 S State St, Westerville
  • 1465 W 86th St, Indianapolis
  • 5650 S Franklin Rd, Indianapolis
  • 6810 Perimeter Loop Rd, Dublin
  • 920 N High St, Columbus
  • 7912 Paragon Rd, Centerville
  • 229 Lafayette St, London

Rating and reporting happen in the app so submissions can be verified and moderated. Browse more on the restaurant map, or check packaged groceries with the product finder. Own a restaurant that skips seed oils? Get listed as seed-oil-free.