TallowTallow
City Barbeque — photo
City Barbeque — photo 2
City Barbeque — photo 3
City Barbeque — photo 4
City Barbeque — photo 5

City Barbeque

78 locations · 1 rating

50/100Okay
Some premade

Verified from Tallow research, Sep 29, 2026

Open in Maps

Directions go to the location you picked — 2511 Blackmon Dr, Decatur.

What the score is made of

Two things, counted the same: seed oils and artificial ingredients. Nothing else moves the number.

  • Seed oils50
  • Artificial ingredients50

Full methodology: how we score restaurants.

What we know

  • Seed oil fryer: Mazola Fryer Oil, soybean oil blend
  • Corn syrup (HFCS): Ken's Honey Mustard dressing

What reviewers said

Tallow research1mo ago

City Barbeque confirmed by email that its fryer oil is a soybean blend, its house mayo (used in the ranch, potato salad and coleslaw) has soybean oil, and its butter is a palm and soybean oil blend used on the Texas toast, corn pudding and desserts. The plain smoked meats themselves are not rubbed in any oil.

City Barbeque answered our questions. The meats are the good part: the whole proteins are smoked on site over hickory and are not rubbed in oil or margarine before or after smoking. Most of what goes around them has soybean oil. The fryer oil is a soybean blend, and they named no fried item that uses anything else, so fries, hush puppies, tenders, fried okra and fried pickles carry it. The house mayo has soybean oil and goes into the ranch, chipotle ranch, potato salad, coleslaw and chocolate cake. Their butter is a palm and soybean oil blend used on the Texas toast, in the corn pudding, on the Triple Que and Bama chicken, and in the cobbler and banana pudding crumble. The two published dressing statements carry preservatives. They did not answer whether the bacon, pastrami and sausage have nitrites. Best order: plain smoked meat, skipping the fried sides, mayo sides and Texas toast.

Common questions

What is in City Barbeque's food?

Tallow checks City Barbeque on two things: whether it cooks in seed oils, and whether the menu carries artificial ingredients like dyes and preservatives. Both count the same, and each is scored below.

Does City Barbeque use seed oils?

Sometimes. City Barbeque scores 50/100 here, so reports are mixed.

Does City Barbeque use artificial ingredients?

Sometimes. City Barbeque scores 50/100 here, so reports are mixed.

Is City Barbeque healthy?

Partly — City Barbeque scores 50/100, which is middling. Tallow rates what a kitchen cooks with, not how many calories are on the plate.

Is City Barbeque's food made fresh?

Partly. Reports say some of City Barbeque's food arrives premade. That's shown as info and doesn't change the score.

City Barbeque locations

Showing 40 of 78

  • 2511 Blackmon Dr, Decatur — the one you picked
  • 2111 Henderson Rd, Columbus
  • 108 S Stygler Rd, Gahanna
  • 3758 W. Powell Road, Powell
  • 600 S State St, Westerville
  • 5979 E Main St, Columbus
  • 2330 N Fairfield Rd, Beavercreek
  • 15033 Flag City Dr, Findlay
  • 5 E Franklin St, Centerville
  • 878 Eastgate North Dr, Cincinnati
  • 7706 Voice of America Centre Dr, West Chester
  • 7402 W Central Ave, Toledo
  • 1501 Gemini Pl, Columbus
  • Huntington Park, Columbus
  • 8026 Burlington Pike, Florence
  • 7863 US 31, Indianapolis
  • 1195 W Church St, Newark
  • 10375 Kenwood Rd, Blue Ash
  • 2261 Stringtown Rd, Grove City
  • 9116 Rockville Rd, Indianapolis
  • 6199 Cleveland Ave, Columbus
  • City Barbeque
  • 3292 Richmond Rd, Lexington
  • 1356 S Rangeline Rd, Carmel
  • 621 W 11th St, Indianapolis
  • 2760 Alexandria Pike, Highland Heights
  • 1305 Kildaire Farm Rd, Cary
  • 9367 Ambleside Dr, Fishers
  • 2187 Harrodsburg Rd, Lexington
  • 110 Cabela Dr, Garner
  • 9429 Viking Center Dr, Louisville
  • 208 West N Carolina 54, Durham
  • 11212 Providence Rd W, Charlotte
  • 1514 Galleria Blvd, Charlotte
  • 9424 Falls of Neuse Rd, Raleigh
  • 8948 J M Keynes Dr Ste 420, Charlotte
  • 15425 Hodges Cir, Huntersville
  • 2870 W Market St, Fairlawn
  • 365 Lake Cook Rd, Deerfield
  • 4210 Johns Creek Pkwy, Johns Creek

Rating and reporting happen in the app so submissions can be verified and moderated. Browse more on the restaurant map, or check packaged groceries with the product finder. Own a restaurant that skips seed oils? Get listed as seed-oil-free.