Chip City's base cookie dough is just butter, flour, sugar and eggs with no oil, but rotating flavors with store-bought add-ins like Hydrox, Biscoff and icing bring in soybean oil, artificial flavors and dyes.
Chip City publishes full ingredient labels for its cookies, and the base dough is genuinely simple: flour, butter, sugar, eggs, cornstarch, vanilla, salt and baking powder, with no seed oil. Of the six current flavors, Chocolate Chip, Milk Chocolate Chip, Nutella Sea Salt and Caramel Apple Cider Doughnut have no seed oil or artificial additives. Cookies N' Cream uses a Hydrox crumb with soybean oil and artificial flavor, and Confetti's sprinkles are not broken down. The rotating flavors are where it goes wrong: 4 of the 6 we read (Cookie Butter, Pumpkin Cheesecake, Red Velvet, Galaxy Brownie) had seed oils, and several had dyes, artificial flavors or preservatives. Stick to the classic chocolate chip and you are in good shape.