TallowTallow

Caseys Carry Out Pizza

110 locations · 1 rating

0/100Avoid
Open in Maps

What the score is made of

Four categories, weighted. Seed oils count three times as much as plastics or ultra-processing, so a poor seed-oil score pulls the overall number down hardest.

  • Seed oil3× weight0
  • Additives2× weight0
  • Plastics0.5× weight
  • NOVA0.5× weight0

Plastics has no ratings yet and count as 0 toward the overall score — an unproven category isn’t a free pass.

Full methodology: how we score restaurants.

What reviewers said

@Fable_X_Tallow3w ago

Casey's publishes a genuine 39-page per-item ingredient document, and it shows their Original Crust - the base of the fifth-largest pizza business in the country - lists both soybean oil and potassium bromate, a dough conditioner banned in the EU, UK and Canada and banned in California from 2027. 196 of 241 food items carry a seed oil and 340 of 345 carry an additive.

Rated from Casey's own "Nutrition and Ingredients" document, updated 7/29/2026, 39 pages of real per-item ingredient statements (store.caseys.com/media/cms/Nutrition-and-Ingredients.pdf, reached from caseys.com/nutrition). Seed oils: 196 of 241 food items name one. Casey's Original Crust - the base of their whole pizza business - lists SOYBEAN OIL, and so do the Thin Crust and Pan Crust. It runs through the breadsticks, the pizza sauces, every dressing, the donuts and pastries, the sandwich breads and the fried sides. No swap offered. The bigger finding is on the same line: Original Crust also lists POTASSIUM BROMATE, a dough conditioner banned in the EU, UK and Canada and banned in California from 2027. It appears in 28 items, all Original Crust pizzas plus the breadsticks. Additives: 340 of 345 items carry at least one. Clean: the meat and cheese toppings, wings, sliders and mac and cheese.

Common questions

What is in Caseys Carry Out Pizza's food?

Tallow reviewers check Caseys Carry Out Pizza on four things: whether it cooks in seed oils, whether the menu carries artificial additives, whether food touches plastic on the way out, and how much of it arrives premade rather than made in the kitchen. The answers to each are scored below.

Does Caseys Carry Out Pizza use seed oils?

Yes. Caseys Carry Out Pizza scores 0/100 here — reviewers report heavy seed oil use.

Does Caseys Carry Out Pizza use artificial additives?

Yes. Caseys Carry Out Pizza scores 0/100 here — reviewers report a lot of artificial additives.

Is Caseys Carry Out Pizza healthy?

Not really — Caseys Carry Out Pizza scores 0/100, a poor score. Tallow rates what a kitchen cooks with, not how many calories are on the plate.

Does Caseys Carry Out Pizza serve premade or ultra-processed food?

Yes. Caseys Carry Out Pizza scores 0/100 here — reviewers report mostly premade or ultra-processed food.

Caseys Carry Out Pizza locations

Showing 40 of 110

  • 601 W Church St, West Salem
  • 507 E State St, Bridgeport
  • 315 N Christy Ave, Sumner
  • 601 S Central Ave, Casey
  • 613 W Porter St, Palestine
  • 383 State Highway 121, Bethany
  • 1104 S Willow St, Effingham
  • 1900 N Peoria Rd, Springfield
  • 510 E Central Ave, Benld
  • 1556 School St, Hillsboro
  • 1551 Hartman Ln, Belleville
  • 175 W Jackson St, Sparta
  • 1203 S Broadway Ave, Salem
  • 401 W Main St, Malden
  • 200 S Main St, Gideon
  • 12686 245th St, Silver Lake
  • 605 N Sibley Ave, Litchfield
  • 217 N Nokomis St, Alexandria
  • 1102 N Main St, Bicknell
  • 1005 E Highway 20, Valentine
  • 1005 E Douglas St, Oneill
  • 1313 Walnut St, Springfield
  • 1790 Lincoln Ave SW, Huron
  • 702 2nd Ave, Sibley
  • 1104 W 18th St, Spencer
  • 1225 N 2nd St, Cherokee
  • 303 E Highway 7, Alta
  • 222 W Milwaukee Ave, Storm Lake
  • 401 E Park Ave, Plainview
  • 201 N Broadway St, Red Oak
  • 405 Main St, Tarkio
  • Park Avenue, Peru
  • 205 W North Ave, Belton
  • 5940 Leavenworth Rd, Kansas City
  • 706 S Central Ave, Marionville
  • 500 Locust St, Pleasant Hill
  • 198 Main St, Polo
  • 403 S Main St, Gallatin
  • 719 Elm St, Chillicothe
  • 117 E Jackson St, Keytesville

Rating and reporting happen in the app so submissions can be verified and moderated. Browse more on the restaurant map, or check packaged groceries with the product finder.