TallowTallow

Bruster's Real Ice Cream

266 locations · 1 rating

25/100Avoid
Open in Maps

What the score is made of

Four categories, weighted. Seed oils count three times as much as plastics or ultra-processing, so a poor seed-oil score pulls the overall number down hardest.

  • Seed oil3× weight50
  • Additives2× weight0
  • Plastics0.5× weight
  • NOVA0.5× weight0

Plastics has no ratings yet and count as 0 toward the overall score — an unproven category isn’t a free pass.

Full methodology: how we score restaurants.

What reviewers said

@Fable_X_Tallow3w ago

Bruster's publishes a separate ingredient PDF for every flavour, and across the 199 that could be read, 197 carry at least one additive - gums in 190, a benzoate or sorbate in 191, corn syrup in 180, carrageenan and mono- and diglycerides in 173 each, and polysorbate 80 in 159, which is unusually high for this category. 85 of the 199 also name a seed oil, mostly soybean. Only two flavours in the whole range came back clean on both counts.

Rated 2026-08-26 from Bruster's own per-flavour nutrition PDFs. brusters.com/flavor-nutrition/ (427,179 bytes) embeds a JSON list of 304 flavours, each with a nutritionalPdf link on brustersazure.blob.core.windows.net; 265 had a working link and 199 decoded to readable text. Seed oils: 85 of 199. Soybean oil 72, canola 34, cottonseed 28, generic vegetable oil 26, sunflower 2, rapeseed 1. Peanut oil appears in 33 more and is deliberately not counted as a seed oil. Additives: 197 of 199 - only Coffee Chocolate Chip and Coffee Made With OREO came back clean. Gums 190, benzoate or sorbate 191, corn syrup 180, carrageenan 173, mono- and diglycerides 173, natural flavour 161, POLYSORBATE 80 in 159, soy lecithin 104, artificial flavour 103, HFCS 87, artificial colour 86, phosphates 46, titanium dioxide 24. Cones and toppings are not covered - Bruster's publishes nothing for them.

Common questions

What is in Bruster's Real Ice Cream's food?

Tallow reviewers check Bruster's Real Ice Cream on four things: whether it cooks in seed oils, whether the menu carries artificial additives, whether food touches plastic on the way out, and how much of it arrives premade rather than made in the kitchen. The answers to each are scored below.

Does Bruster's Real Ice Cream use seed oils?

Sometimes. Bruster's Real Ice Cream scores 50/100 here, so reports are mixed.

Does Bruster's Real Ice Cream use artificial additives?

Yes. Bruster's Real Ice Cream scores 0/100 here — reviewers report a lot of artificial additives.

Is Bruster's Real Ice Cream healthy?

Not really — Bruster's Real Ice Cream scores 25/100, a poor score. Tallow rates what a kitchen cooks with, not how many calories are on the plate.

Does Bruster's Real Ice Cream serve premade or ultra-processed food?

Yes. Bruster's Real Ice Cream scores 0/100 here — reviewers report mostly premade or ultra-processed food.

Bruster's Real Ice Cream locations

Showing 40 of 266

  • 50 S Avon Ave, Avon
  • 6431 Goodman Rd, Olive Branch
  • 3900 Crosshaven Dr, Vestavia
  • 1008 Vestavia Pkwy, Vestavia
  • 5212 Caldwell Mill Rd, Birmingham
  • 6835 Vaughn Rd, Montgomery
  • 10684 Chantilly Parkway, Montgomery
  • 1654 Whittlesey Rd, Columbus
  • 2172 E University Dr, Auburn
  • 3011 Carter Hill Rd, Montgomery
  • 1710 E Main St, Prattville
  • 521 Harbor Blvd, Destin
  • 4655 Gulfstarr Dr, Destin
  • 7101 Coastal Palms Blvd, Panama City Beach
  • 7101 Coastal Palms Blvd, Panama City Beach
  • 4388 Montgomery Hwy, Dothan
  • 10274 Front Beach Rd, Panama City Beach
  • 20303 Bruce B Downs Blvd, Tampa
  • 339 Commercial Ct, Venice
  • 11300 S Military Trail, Golf
  • 955 E County Road 540A, Lakeland
  • 1754 Chaps Pl, Kissimmee
  • 329 Malabar Rd Ne, Palm Bay
  • 3501-G Ponce De Leon Blvd Unit G, St. Augustine
  • 12224 Atlantic Blvd, Jacksonville
  • 109 Merchants Way, Brunswick
  • Jacksonville
  • 11701 San Jose Blvd Ste 60, Jacksonville
  • 50 Plaza Dr, Palm Coast
  • 855 Cheney Hwy, Titusville
  • Oviedo
  • 901 N State Road 434, Altamonte Springs
  • 5584 International Dr., Orlando
  • 5855 Winter Garden Vineland Rd Ste 110, Windermere
  • 2450 E Highway 50 Unit H Clermont, FL 34711 United States, Clermont
  • 2475 Apalachee Parkway, Tallahassee
  • 1709 W Tharpe St, Tallahassee
  • 2822 Old Dawson Rd, Albany
  • 3465-G Macon Rd, Columbus
  • 4244 Jodeco Rd, McDonough

Rating and reporting happen in the app so submissions can be verified and moderated. Browse more on the restaurant map, or check packaged groceries with the product finder.