Bruegger's publishes full ingredient lists: the standard bagels and cream cheeses have no seed oil, but every egg sandwich is cooked in a soybean oil butter blend, the mayo is soybean oil, and the sausages carry TBHQ and BHT.
Bruegger's 2026 nutrition guide lists ingredients for every item, which made this easy to check. The good part: the standard bagels are simple (the Plain is flour, water, malt, salt, yeast and gluten, no oil), all the cream cheeses are seed oil free, and there is no fryer. The bad part is almost everything you put on or around the bagel. The eggs are cooked in a butter blend that is palm and soybean oil, so every egg and egg white sandwich has seed oil, and the mayo, chipotle mayo, ciabatta roll and sundried tomato spread do too. On additives, the bacon, ham and pastrami are nitrite cured, the pork and turkey sausage contain TBHQ and BHT, and several spreads and coffee syrups use potassium sorbate. Best order: a plain or everything bagel with plain cream cheese, or a deli sandwich without mayo. Skip the egg sandwiches.




