TallowTallow
Andy's Frozen Custard — photo
Andy's Frozen Custard — photo 2
Andy's Frozen Custard — photo 3
Andy's Frozen Custard — photo 4
Andy's Frozen Custard — photo 5

Andy's Frozen Custard

186 locations · 1 rating

50/100Okay
Mostly premade

Verified from Tallow research, Sep 19, 2026

Open in Maps

Directions go to the location you picked — 9535 Metcalf Ave, Overland Park.

What the score is made of

Two things, counted the same: seed oils and artificial ingredients. Nothing else moves the number.

  • Seed oils50
  • Artificial ingredients50

Full methodology: how we score restaurants.

What we know

  • No fryer

What reviewers said

Tallow research2mo ago

Andy's publishes ingredient statements for only its two custard bases, and neither names an oil - the one seed-oil link is a mono- and diglyceride emulsifier their own FAQ says is sourced from soybean oil. The bases are clean of dyes and preservatives, but the mix and every topping arrive premade, so almost nothing here is made from scratch in store.

Andy's publishes ingredient statements for two things only: the vanilla and chocolate custard bases. Their nutrition sheet says so outright - "Nutritional Information for Custard Only. We do not provide nutritional information for toppings." Neither statement names any oil. I still scored seed oils as some rather than none, because their own FAQ says the mono and diglycerides in the custard mix are "sourced from soybean oil", putting a soybean-derived emulsifier in every custard item; about 55 toppings carry no statement at all. There is no fryer and nothing published about swaps. On additives the bases are better than expected: vanilla has no artificial ingredient, chocolate lists "Natural and Artificial Vanilla", both carry mono and diglycerides and three gums, and there is no dye, TBHQ, BHA, BHT, titanium dioxide, benzoate, polysorbate, propylene glycol, nitrite or HFCS. But the mix is bought in and so is every branded topping, so almost nothing here is made from scratch in store.

Common questions

What is in Andy's Frozen Custard's food?

Tallow checks Andy's Frozen Custard on two things: whether it cooks in seed oils, and whether the menu carries artificial ingredients like dyes and preservatives. Both count the same, and each is scored below.

Does Andy's Frozen Custard use seed oils?

Sometimes. Andy's Frozen Custard scores 50/100 here, so reports are mixed.

Does Andy's Frozen Custard use artificial ingredients?

Sometimes. Andy's Frozen Custard scores 50/100 here, so reports are mixed.

Is Andy's Frozen Custard healthy?

Partly — Andy's Frozen Custard scores 50/100, which is middling. Tallow rates what a kitchen cooks with, not how many calories are on the plate.

Is Andy's Frozen Custard's food made fresh?

Mostly not. Reports say most of Andy's Frozen Custard's food arrives premade. That's shown as info and doesn't change the score.

Andy's Frozen Custard locations

Showing 40 of 186

  • 9535 Metcalf Ave, Overland Park — the one you picked
  • 104 Southwest Pkwy, College Station
  • 1 Kings Plz, Lake Ozark
  • 1327 Red Wolf Blvd, Jonesboro
  • 3415 W 76 Country Blvd, Branson
  • 610 Cooper Dr N, Columbia
  • 2119 N Glenstone Ave, Springfield
  • 3147 E Sunshine St, Springfield
  • 2726 S Campbell Ave, Springfield
  • 6106 S Broadway Ave, Tyler
  • 2205 W Walnut St, Rogers
  • 4420 S Campbell Ave, Springfield
  • 809 N Kingshighway St, Cape Girardeau
  • 260 S Weber Rd, Bolingbrook
  • 4820 Osage Beach Pkwy, Osage Beach
  • 9507 S Cicero Ave, Oak Lawn
  • 232 E Highland Dr, Jonesboro
  • 2934 S Range Line Rd, Joplin
  • 1300 E Battlefield Rd, Springfield
  • 8251 E 102nd St, Tulsa
  • 1523 W Martin Luther King Blvd, Fayetteville
  • 311 S Kirkwood Rd, Kirkwood
  • 5745 S La Grange Rd, Countryside
  • 8041 S Harlem Ave, Bridgeview
  • 1700 E Palm Valley Blvd, Round Rock
  • 1200 Westport Rd, Kansas City
  • 18601 Limestone Commercial Dr, Pflugerville
  • 4844 S Yale Ave, Tulsa
  • 2375 Dave Ward Dr, Conway
  • 598 NE State Route 291, Lee's Summit
  • 800 E Kenosha St, Broken Arrow
  • 1733 E Hebron Pkwy, Carrollton
  • 15501 Manchester Rd, Ballwin
  • 1000 Northwest Missouri 7, Blue Springs
  • 1200 US-34, Oswego
  • 1210 N Bell Blvd, Cedar Park
  • 5801 NW Expressway, Warr Acres
  • 3505 River Point Pkwy, Englewood
  • 1604 S Hanley Rd, St Louis
  • 9310 Lebanon Rd, Frisco

Rating and reporting happen in the app so submissions can be verified and moderated. Browse more on the restaurant map, or check packaged groceries with the product finder. Own a restaurant that skips seed oils? Get listed as seed-oil-free.