TallowTallow
Tallow Research

Steak 'n Shake's sales are up 13.8%. Here is what changed, and what is still unclear

Steak 'n Shake's same-store sales rose 13.8% after tallow fries, grass-fed beef and seed oil free buns. What the 2026 beef study shows and what is unanswered.

Emily Harper

A basket of golden French fries next to a burger on a wooden table.

Steak 'n Shake spent 2025 and 2026 rebuilding its menu around one idea: fewer processed ingredients. Now there are numbers to look at. Parent company Biglari Holdings reported on August 7 that Steak n Shake's second-quarter same-store sales rose 13.8% across its domestic company-operated and franchise-partner-operated restaurants.

That is a big number for a burger chain. It is also only the sales side of the story. Here is the full list of what changed, what the nutrition research does and does not say about it, and what a menu claim can't tell you.

The timeline, in order

  • Early 2025: fries, tots, onion rings and chicken tenders move to 100% beef tallow. (We covered the fryer switch in our earlier Steak 'n Shake breakdown.)
  • August 2025: cane sugar Coca-Cola is added alongside the standard version.
  • December 2025: A2 milk for shakes, per Fox News.
  • February 12, 2026: the chain announced it would remove microwaves from about 390 U.S. restaurants by April 15, citing "traditional cooking methods only."
  • June 1, 2026: every Steakburger switches to 100% grass-fed, grass-finished beef, announced May 13.
  • October 5, 2026: buns go seed oil free and are finished with Grade AA Wisconsin butter, as reported October 6.

Chief MAHA Officer Michael Boes framed the strategy this way: "Real ingredients taste better than synthetic additives."

The grass-fed claim: what the research shows

The biggest ingredient change is the beef. A 2026 study in the Journal of Animal Science by Varre and colleagues compared commercial North American beef: 253 grass-fed samples and 84 grain-fed samples. The differences were real:

MeasureGrass-fedGrain-fed
Omega-6 to omega-3 ratio2.14 : 18.28 : 1
Conjugated linoleic acid (CLA)0.49%0.31%
Iron (mg per 100 g)2.291.92
Total saturated fat51.25%47.59%

Two things matter here. First, saturated fat was higher in the grass-fed samples, so "grass-fed" is not the same as "lower in saturated fat." Second, the spread inside grass-fed beef was huge: omega-6 to omega-3 ratios ranged from 0.62 to 11.45. The authors themselves called for clearer definitions and more transparent labeling, because the production claim alone doesn't tell you what is in the meat.

The caveats the sales number skips

Price. When asked whether the grass-fed switch would raise menu prices, CEO Michael Boes did not answer, according to IBTimes. The same report cites U.S. cattle inventory of 86.2 million head, the lowest since 1951, and an Oklahoma State economist saying there is nothing to suggest relief from high beef prices.

Sourcing. The chain has not publicly detailed where the new grass-fed supply comes from, and some observers have asked whether volume at this scale needs imports given limited U.S. grass-fed supply. That is an open question, not a finding.

Seed oils. Fox notes the American Heart Association said in 2024 that "there's no reason to avoid seed oils." Tallow is still mostly saturated fat. Avoiding seed oils is a preference with some reasoning behind it, and the heart-health evidence is still contested.

Microwaves. The FDA says microwave cooking does not reduce nutritional value any more than conventional cooking. Removing them is a quality and branding choice, not a safety one.

What you can actually check yourself

A menu board tells you the last step of a supply chain. It doesn't list every ingredient in the bun, the sauces, the shake base or the seasoning. That is where the gaps tend to be.

This is the problem Tallow was built for. Search a restaurant or product and see what is actually in it: the Steak 'n Shake page on Tallow is a start, and if you want to cook the same way at home, you can look up Steak n Shake's grass-fed beef tallow on Tallow and see how it scores. Next time a chain announces a "real ingredients" overhaul, scan the packaged food you buy with the same skepticism and let the lab data decide.