Rickets is rising again: what cola and phosphate additives do and don't do to kids' bones
Rickets is rising and vitamin D is the main cause, but cola and phosphate additives get blamed too. What the studies show, and where phosphates hide.
Emily Harper
Rickets is the disease most people file under Victorian chimney-sweeps and cod liver oil. It is not gone. In England, hospital records show reported rickets cases rising from 183 in 1995-96 to 762 in 2010-11, and the NIH says rickets incidence is increasing globally, "even in the United States and Europe."
Online, that rise gets tangled up with a second story: that cola and the phosphate added to processed food are quietly thinning kids' bones. Part of that story is backed by real studies. Part of it is much shakier than the headlines make it sound. Here is where the line sits.
What rickets actually is, and what usually causes it
In children, rickets is a failure of bone to mineralize properly, which leaves bones soft and can cause skeletal deformities. The NIH's vitamin D fact sheet is blunt about the main cause: vitamin D deficiency. Fortifying milk and other staples with vitamin D starting in the 1930s made rickets rare in the US, but the NIH says incidence is now rising again, especially among immigrants from African, Middle-Eastern and Asian countries. Prolonged exclusive breastfeeding without vitamin D supplementation can cause it in infants, and in the United States it is most common among breastfed Black infants and children (NIH Office of Dietary Supplements, vitamin D).
The England numbers come from a 2012 UK Parliament debate, which cited a written answer on hospital data. One caution from that same debate: the 183 and 762 figures count hospital episodes, and one child can be admitted more than once. The count of individual patients diagnosed rose from 134 to 395 over the same stretch, which the speaker called the better measure. Still roughly triple (Hansard, 4 September 2012).
One more thing worth knowing before you panic about your toddler's legs. Knock knees are a normal part of development between ages 2 and 4 and usually improve by about age 7 or 8. Rickets is one of the causes doctors look at when knock knees start or get worse later, usually after age 6 (KidsHealth).
The honest bottom line on rickets itself: it is mainly about vitamin D, not soda or additives. The cola and phosphate question is about a related thing, how strong bones get built during childhood.
Why childhood is the window that matters
Bone is built early. One review puts it this way: up to 90 percent of peak bone mass is acquired by age 18 in girls and age 20 in boys (Caradonna and Rigante, 2009). Whatever helps or hurts that process matters most before the end of high school.
The cola studies: what they found, and what they did not
Two studies drive most of the claim.
| Wyshak, 2000 | Tucker et al., 2006 (Framingham) | |
|---|---|---|
| Who | 460 ninth- and tenth-grade girls at one urban high school | 1,413 women and 1,125 men |
| Design | Cross-sectional, self-reported fractures | Bone density scans, food frequency questionnaire |
| Headline result | Carbonated drinks and fractures: odds ratio 3.14. Among physically active girls, cola: odds ratio 4.94 | Daily cola drinkers: hip bone density 3.7% lower (femoral neck) and 5.4% lower (Ward's area) than people who had less than one cola a month |
| Where it did not show up | The authors say the mechanism "has neither been fully explored nor determined" | Not in men, not at the spine, and not for non-cola carbonated drinks |
Sources: Wyshak, Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine and Tucker et al., American Journal of Clinical Nutrition.
In the Framingham study, diet cola showed similar results and decaffeinated cola weaker ones. That is interesting, because diet cola has no sugar, so sugar alone is an unlikely explanation. The study's own conclusion was that more research is needed to confirm the findings.
Keep the limits in mind. Both are observational. An odds ratio of 4.94 comes with a wide confidence interval (1.79 to 13.62), which means the estimate is imprecise. Neither study can show that cola caused the broken bones or the lower density.
The plot twist: cola is not actually a phosphorus bomb
If phosphoric acid were the culprit, you would expect cola to be loaded with phosphorus. It is not. Using the NIH's food table:
| Food | Phosphorus per serving |
|---|---|
| Milk, 2%, 1 cup | 226 mg |
| Chicken breast, roasted, 3 oz | 182 mg |
| Egg, 1 large, hard boiled | 86 mg |
| Cola, 1 cup | 18 mg |
(NIH Office of Dietary Supplements, phosphorus)
The Framingham authors found the same thing in their own data: total phosphorus intake was not significantly higher in daily cola drinkers than in non-drinkers. What was lower was their calcium-to-phosphorus ratio. The NIH notes that high phosphorus with low calcium can raise parathyroid hormone, but says "evidence is mixed" on whether that actually lowers bone density. One national survey of 1,228 older Americans found no trend between the calcium-to-phosphorus ratio and hip or spine bone density (Anderson et al., 2017).
So where does that leave cola? The most defensible read: heavy cola drinking travels with lower bone density and more fractures in some groups, but nobody has pinned down why. Phosphoric acid is a suspect, not a convicted one. Sugar, caffeine and simply drinking cola instead of milk are other candidates.
The bigger phosphate story is in the processed food aisle
This is the part the cola debate tends to bury. Phosphate additives are everywhere, and the body handles them differently from the phosphorus in a chicken breast.
- How common: A review of the labels on 2,394 best-selling grocery products in northeast Ohio found phosphorus additives in 44%. They showed up in 72% of prepared frozen foods, 70% of dry food mixes, 65% of packaged meat and 54% of soups (León et al., 2013).
- How much: Additive-containing foods averaged 67 mg more phosphorus per 100 g than matched foods without them, and sample meals built from additive foods had 736 mg more phosphorus a day than additive-free ones.
- How well it is absorbed: The NIH puts absorption of phosphorus from phosphate additives at about 70%, versus 40% to 70% for the phosphorus naturally in food (animal sources absorb better than plant sources). It estimates additives add 300 to 1,000 mg to daily intake.
- Intake is already high: Average daily phosphorus from food is 1,189 mg for US women and 1,596 mg for US men, against a 700 mg recommended amount for adults. Teens aged 14 to 18 are recommended 1,250 mg, and kids 2 to 19 average 1,237 mg.
- Regulators have flagged children: Europe's food safety agency set a group safe intake of 40 mg of phosphorus per kg of body weight per day in 2019. In its exposure estimates, toddlers and children exceeded it at average and high intakes, and so did infants from 12 weeks to 11 months. The limit does not apply to people with moderately to severely reduced kidney function (EFSA, 2019).
- FDA researchers have raised concerns too: A 2013 review by researchers at the FDA's food safety center argued that phosphorus intake in excess of needs may disrupt the hormones that regulate phosphate, calcium and vitamin D, and may contribute to bone loss, while noting that few studies link dietary phosphorus to small changes in blood phosphate (Calvo and Uribarri, 2013).
Now the balance. The NIH says high phosphorus intakes "rarely produce adverse effects in healthy people," and that studies are split on whether intakes above 1,000 mg a day do harm. Phosphoric acid is on the FDA's list of substances generally recognized as safe when used under good manufacturing practice (21 CFR 182.1073). No study we found shows that phosphate additives cause rickets. Where the concern is strongest is people with chronic kidney disease, who cannot clear phosphate well and are advised to limit it.
How phosphates show up on a label
The NIH lists phosphoric acid, sodium phosphate and sodium polyphosphate as the common phosphate additives. The ingredient list is where you find them, so look for any ingredient with "phosphate" or "phosphoric" in the name, including disodium phosphate and sodium tripolyphosphate.
The usual places:
- Cola: phosphoric acid
- Deli turkey and ham, and packaged meat: sodium phosphates keep meat moist
- Frozen prepared foods: phosphate salts for moisture and texture
- Processed cheese: sodium phosphate as an emulsifier
What helps kids' bones, in order of evidence
- Vitamin D. The NIH recommended amount is 600 IU a day for ages 1 to 18, and 400 IU for infants. How much your child needs, and whether to supplement, is a question for the pediatrician, especially for breastfed infants.
- Enough calcium, mostly from food. Milk and dairy are also the biggest source of phosphorus in the US diet, at about 20% of intake, so milk is not something to cut, but it is a reason to look at the other sources of phosphorus first.
- Cut the obvious extras. Swapping a daily cola for water or milk is a low-effort change with no known downside.
- Pick fewer foods with phosphate additives. That is where the extra, well-absorbed phosphorus comes from.
Where Tallow fits
You do not need to memorize additive names at the store. Scan the barcode with Tallow and the ingredients are broken out for you, with additives that cost a product points flagged.
A few examples from the aisles above:
- Cola: Coca-Cola Original Taste on Tallow scores 0 and lists phosphoric acid among its deductions. Coca-Cola made with cane sugar on Tallow scores 53 but still lists phosphoric acid. If you want bubbles with nothing else, Spindrift lemon sparkling water on Tallow is carbonated water and lemon juice and scores 100.
- Deli turkey: Oscar Mayer Deli Fresh oven roasted turkey breast on Tallow scores 40 and lists sodium phosphates. Applegate Organic oven roasted turkey breast on Tallow is turkey, water, sea salt, potato starch, chicken broth and rosemary extract, and scores 100.
- Cheese: Velveeta processed cheese loaf on Tallow scores 22 and lists both sodium phosphate and calcium phosphate. Organic Valley organic sharp cheddar on Tallow is milk, salt and enzyme, and scores 97.
None of this means one can of cola breaks a bone. It means the evidence on childhood bones points to vitamin D, calcium and a diet built on fewer heavily processed foods, and the label is the fastest way to see how much of the second kind is in your cart. Scan what is in your fridge with Tallow tonight, start with the cola, deli meat and cheese, and see which ones are worth swapping before they go in this week's lunchboxes.