TallowTallow
Tallow Research

Is 3D-printed salmon real salmon? What's in the Perfecta patty, and what it doesn't have

The 3D-printed salmon in US stores has no fish: it is a soy and rice patty colored with beetroot. The label, the protein gap, the omega-3 claim and the allergen mismatch.

Emily Harper

A seared salmon fillet on a black plate with zucchini and carrot ribbons, spinach and a lime wedge.

Short answer: no. The "3D-printed salmon" that reached US grocery stores this fall contains no salmon and no fish at all. It is a plant-based patty, and the pink color comes from beetroot powder. Snopes rated the underlying claim "True" because the product exists and is on shelves, but "3D-printed salmon" describes how it is shaped, not what it is made of.

What the product is

Israeli food-tech company Steakholder Foods says it put its Perfecta line into retail stores across the Northeastern US starting September 3, 2026, through KeHE Distributors. The line has five items, and two are seafood-style: a salmon patty and a white fish patty. Steakholder's launch announcement does not name the stores. IBTimes UK makes the same point and reports that, according to Allrecipes, the packaging does not say the products are 3D-printed. The boxes call the food "plant-based."

We covered the steak side of this launch in what's in Perfecta and the store question in where Perfecta is sold. This post is only about the salmon.

What is in the salmon patty

Steakholder publishes the salmon patty's ingredient list on its business-facing premix page, and the Open Food Facts entry for the retail patties matches it, in this order:

  1. Water
  2. Rice flour
  3. Soy protein
  4. Vegetable oils
  5. Potato starch
  6. Methylcellulose and sodium alginate (stabilizers)
  7. Flavors, salt, maltodextrin
  8. Disodium ribonucleotides (E635, a flavor enhancer)
  9. Vegetable protein hydrolysate
  10. Beetroot powder
  11. Vitamin B12, iron and zinc

There is no fish, no fish oil and no algae on that list. Open Food Facts, which is volunteer-edited, estimates water at about 54% and rice flour at about 17%, so water and rice are most of it. Beetroot powder sits near the end of the list, which means it is a small amount used for color.

Is it just the white fish patty with a pink dye?

Some viral posts say the salmon and white fish patties share the same ingredient list apart from the beetroot powder. We could not confirm that, because we did not find a published white fish patty list to compare. If you have both boxes, compare the back panels; it takes a minute.

Salmon vs the patty: protein and omega-3

People eat salmon mostly for protein and for the omega-3 fats EPA and DHA. Here is how the patty compares:

Perfecta salmon pattyRaw Atlantic salmon
Protein per 100 gAbout 8 g (4 g per 50 g patty, per Green Queen via IBTimes)About 20 g (USDA, as cited by IBTimes)
Where the protein comes fromSoy protein and rice flourFish
EPA and DHA omega-3No fish or algae source on the listNaturally present

Steakholder's premix page lists 5.6 g of protein per 100 g, which is a different basis (the business premix) than the retail figure, so the two numbers do not contradict each other. The same page calls the patty "rich in Omega-3 fatty acids." The ingredient list names only "vegetable oils" without saying which ones. Some plant oils carry a different omega-3 (ALA), which is not the EPA and DHA found in fish, and we could not find a published omega-3 number for the finished patty. If omega-3 is why you buy salmon, ask Steakholder for the figure before assuming the patty replaces it.

The laxative ingredient

The viral video also mentions "a chemical used in laxatives." That is methylcellulose, and Snopes confirms it is on the list. It is a plant-fiber binder used across plant-based meat, and Snopes notes the FDA has approved this kind of use in food. It is why the patty holds together, not a sign that something is wrong. We went deeper on it in our Perfecta ingredients post.

The allergen question

The premix page lists the allergens as soybeans and the gluten grains "wheat, rye, barley, oats, spelt," with possible traces of celery and mustard. The Open Food Facts listing for the retail patty shows soy only. We did not see the physical box, and a volunteer-edited database can be incomplete, so we cannot say which one is right. If you avoid gluten, read the printed allergen statement on the package you are holding rather than the front of the box.

Does it need FDA approval or a "lab-grown" label?

No. The federal rules for food made with cultured animal cells cover food grown from animal cells. According to Snopes, the FDA said a product made from plant ingredients using 3D printing "does not appear to involve cultured cells of any type," and that it does not approve finished foods or manufacturing processes. The ingredients still have to be safe for their use. So nothing requires "3D-printed" on the box.

Is 3D-printed salmon sold anywhere else?

Yes, and it is not new. Austrian company Revo Foods has sold a 3D-printed mycoprotein salmon alternative, THE FILET, since 2023, according to Green Queen. EIT Food describes it on shelves in more than 20 European markets. Its base is mycoprotein rather than rice and soy. Retail availability may have changed since that coverage.

How to buy real salmon instead

  • Look for a one-ingredient label: the fish and nothing else.
  • Treat any "salmon" that lists only plants, with beetroot or another colorant, as a plant patty.
  • If the package says plant-based, it is plant-based, whatever the picture on the front looks like.

Scan the barcode of a seafood product in the Tallow app to see its full ingredient list and what each ingredient does.