Ben & Jerry's, Halo Top, David, Breyers and Blue Bell: the footnote each ice cream brand leaves off the carton
Glyphosate, erythritol, EPG, a 10% milkfat rule and a record fine: five ice cream brands, the sources, and the context each one needs.
Emily Harper
Ice cream is supposed to be the simple one: cream, milk, sugar, eggs. Yet five of the biggest names in the freezer aisle each come with a footnote most shoppers never see. One has a weed killer residue story, one leans on a sweetener a major cardiology lab has questioned, one uses a fat your body is not built to digest, one can't legally say "ice cream" on some of its tubs, and one has a federal criminal record. Here is each footnote, with the sources, and with the context that keeps it honest.
Ben & Jerry's: glyphosate in 10 of 11 pints (in tiny amounts)
In July 2017 the Organic Consumers Association reported that 10 of 11 Ben & Jerry's samples tested positive for glyphosate, the active ingredient in Roundup, or for AMPA, its main breakdown product, or both. The lab, Health Research Institute Laboratories, found as much as 1.74 parts per billion in Chocolate Fudge Brownie. Cherry Garcia was the only flavor with nothing detected.
Two things matter here. First, the amounts are very small: the testing lab itself calculated that a child would have to eat 145,000 eight-ounce servings a day to exceed the EPA's allowed level. Second, all sides in the dispute believed the residue came from add-ins like peanut butter and cookie dough, not from the cream.
The reason it still gets attention is the classification. The WHO's cancer agency IARC rated glyphosate "probably carcinogenic to humans" (Group 2A) in 2015, based on limited human evidence and sufficient animal evidence. That is a hazard rating, not a risk rating, and several regulators and expert panels disagree with it. Our read: the dose is tiny, the debate is real, and the 2017 test is a snapshot from years ago, so treat it as a reason to look at add-ins, not as a verdict on the brand today. You can see how Ben & Jerry's Vanilla looks on Tallow (it scores 33).
Halo Top: the erythritol question
Halo Top gets its low calorie count partly from erythritol, a sugar alcohol. Per-serving figures reported for Halo Top put it at roughly 4 to 5 grams, which works out to about 16 to 20 grams in a four-serving pint.
Why that number is worth knowing: in a Cleveland Clinic study, healthy volunteers drank water sweetened with 30 grams of erythritol or 30 grams of glucose. Their blood erythritol rose more than 1,000-fold, and every measure of platelet clotting response went up after erythritol but not after sugar. An earlier Nature Medicine paper found that heart patients with high erythritol levels were about twice as likely to have a major cardiac event over the next three years.
The honest caveats: these are short-term lab measurements and an observational link, not proof that a pint of Halo Top causes a clot, and a pint is below the 30 grams used in the experiment. If you eat it occasionally, this is not a panic. If you eat a pint a night, it is worth a second look. Halo Top Vanilla Bean scores 69 on Tallow.
David: a fat engineered to pass through you
David's high-protein ice cream gets its low fat count from EPG (esterified propoxylated glycerol), a modified plant fat that is almost completely undigestible and counts as about 0.7 calories per gram instead of 9. It has cleared the FDA's GRAS notice process, but largely on the manufacturer's own safety case rather than an independent FDA review. Because it replaces cream, the carton says "frozen dessert," not ice cream: under FDA rules, ice cream needs at least 10% milkfat.
EPG is what the product is built around, so it is worth knowing before you buy. David Vanilla Bean High Protein Ice Cream scores 5 on Tallow.
Breyers: some tubs aren't legally ice cream
Several Breyers tubs say "frozen dairy dessert" because they fall short of the same federal definition: at least 10% milkfat and 20% milk solids. We broke down which brands pass and fail in our Klondike, Breyers and Dairy Queen breakdown, and covered the Breyers lactose-free line's fermentation-made whey in this post. The takeaway is that the same brand can sell both kinds. Breyers Natural Vanilla scores 77 on Tallow, while the Cookies & Cream Frozen Dairy Dessert scores 5.
Blue Bell: the largest criminal food safety penalty on record
In 2015 a listeria outbreak was traced to Blue Bell. The CDC counted 10 people infected across Arizona, Kansas, Oklahoma and Texas, all hospitalized, with three deaths in Kansas. The Kansas cases were all linked to one production line at the Brenham, Texas creamery. Blue Bell recalled all its products on April 20, 2015.
In 2020 the company pleaded guilty to two misdemeanor counts of distributing adulterated ice cream and was ordered to pay $17.25 million, the largest criminal penalty ever in a U.S. food safety case. Its former president, Paul Kruse, was indicted on wire fraud and conspiracy counts; the indictment alleges he ordered a listeria testing program stopped. Those are allegations in an indictment, not findings by a jury.
This is a story about a past failure, not a claim about today's tubs. Blue Bell Natural Vanilla Bean scores 85 on Tallow, while the Homemade Vanilla scores 5, which shows how much the formula, not just the brand, drives the number.
What to look for instead
- The word "ice cream" on the carton, not "frozen dairy dessert" or "frozen dessert."
- Short ingredients: milk, cream, sugar, eggs. Be wary of long gum lists.
- No sugar alcohols or engineered fats if you want to avoid the two debates above.
- Be choosy about the add-ins. In the 2017 test the glyphosate story was about the peanut butter and cookie dough, not the base.
Two options that score well on Tallow: Straus Family Creamery Organic Vanilla Bean scores 95 (Straus describes itself as the first 100% certified organic creamery in the U.S.), and Ice Cream for Bears Honey Honey Honey Swirl also scores 95.
Skip the label homework
You just read five brands, five different problems, and five sources. Nobody wants to do that in the freezer aisle. Scan any carton with Tallow and you get a 0 to 100 score, every flagged ingredient, whether the product has been lab tested, and a cleaner swap on the same shelf. Look up your usual pint before it goes in the cart.