TallowTallow
Tallow Research

Is Fairlife Core Power the most plastic-contaminated food? What Consumer Reports found

A viral reel says Fairlife Core Power had the most phthalates of any food tested. Here is what Consumer Reports found in 2024, the real ranking and what to check.

Emily Harper

A chocolate milkshake in a clear cup topped with whipped cream, a cookie and chocolate sauce.

A reel going around says Fairlife Core Power chocolate shake had the most plastic chemicals of any food Consumer Reports tested, "higher than every fast food item." The first half is close. The second half does not match the published numbers.

Here is what Consumer Reports (CR) actually found, what it wrote to Fairlife, and what is on record about the shake today.

The short answer

  • Is it real? Yes. CR tested the Fairlife Core Power High Protein Chocolate Milk Shake and found a lot of phthalates in it. CR's own letter to Fairlife puts the reading at 24,928 nanograms per serving.
  • Was it the highest of any food tested? No. CR's own advocacy page says the shake had "among the highest levels of phthalates of any product it tested." Two other products had higher figures in the coverage of the same study (below).
  • Is this new? No. The test was published in January 2024 and CR's letter to Fairlife is dated February 22, 2024. The reel is recirculating an old study.
  • Did it break a legal limit? Not according to the reporting on the study. News coverage of the CR test said none of the phthalate levels found exceeded limits set by US and European regulators. CR's point was that no level has been confirmed safe, not that a rule was broken.

What Consumer Reports tested

CR tested 85 supermarket and fast foods for plastic chemicals called phthalates and bisphenols. Phthalates turned up in 84 of the 85. Bisphenols, including BPA, were in 79% of the samples. The only product with no phthalates was a Polar raspberry lime seltzer.

Phthalates are plasticizers, chemicals that make plastic soft and flexible. They get into food from packaging and from plastic tubing, conveyor belts and gloves used during processing, which is why they show up in so many products. For the longer explainer on how they get in, read our post on phthalates in fast food.

Where the Fairlife shake ranks

The reel says the shake was higher than every fast food item. These are the figures reported from the same CR study:

ProductPhthalates per servingSource
Annie's Organic Cheesy Ravioli53,579 ngKSL, Jan 2024 (highest supermarket food)
Wendy's Crispy Chicken Nuggets33,980 ngKSL, Jan 2024
Fairlife Core Power High Protein Chocolate Milk Shake24,928 ngCR letter to Fairlife

On those numbers the Wendy's nuggets and the Annie's ravioli both came in higher than the shake. So "highest of any food tested" and "higher than every fast food item" are not supported by what we could find. "Among the highest" is.

One caution on the number itself. The 24,928 figure comes straight from CR's letter, which we read. Some secondary write-ups give a lower figure for the same shake, and we could not reconcile the two from public documents, so treat the exact number as CR's reading of the samples it tested in 2024, not a measurement of every bottle.

What Consumer Reports asked Fairlife to do

CR's food policy director wrote to Fairlife's CEO on February 22, 2024. The letter asked the company to commit to reducing plasticizers, to test its production process for the points where they enter, and to respond by March 14, 2024.

The letter makes three arguments worth knowing:

  1. Existing tolerable daily intake levels for some phthalates "do not reflect the most current scientific knowledge" and are not protective enough, in CR's view.
  2. The effects may be cumulative, so steady exposure to small amounts could add up.
  3. Some products in the test had much lower levels than others, which CR says shows the chemicals can be reduced even if they cannot be avoided completely.

We could not find a public response from Fairlife to the letter. That is not proof there was none, only that we did not find one.

What the lab data on Tallow shows for the shake

Lab results are a different measurement from CR's, and the units do not line up (CR reports nanograms per serving, lab results on Tallow are parts per billion), so do not compare the two directly. Here is what the Fairlife Core Power Chocolate page on Tallow lists, as read on October 27, 2026:

  • DEHP (a phthalate): 14 ppb, shown against a 6 ppb reference. That reference is the US EPA drinking-water limit, which Tallow applies to food as the tightest published number. The EU food-contact limit is looser, so this is a strict yardstick and not a food-law violation.
  • Dibutyl phthalate: 17 ppb, 14% of the EU limit shown.
  • Dimethylphthalate: 4.07 ppb, 41% of the reference shown.
  • BPA, BPF and BPS: not detected.

Tallow's page also flags the shake as ultra-processed with several ingredients to avoid, and gives it a score of 0 (Avoid). Several of the other contaminants it tests for were not detected.

What to do with this

You cannot see phthalates on a label, and a 2024 study does not tell you what is in the bottle in your fridge. CR's own advice from the study is to limit high-fat foods, since higher fat has been linked to higher phthalate levels, and to cut down on plastic in your own kitchen.

If you want the specific product, not the headline, that is where a scanner helps. Scan a Core Power or any other protein shake with Tallow and you can see whether it has been lab tested, which plastic chemicals were measured and how they compare to published limits, instead of trying to work it out from a viral clip. You can start with the Core Power chocolate shake on Tallow, and search any other shake you drink in the app.