Is Chipotle's steak real? The "Play-Doh" video, sous vide and the 53-ingredient claim
A viral clip calls Chipotle's steak Play-Doh. Here is how Chipotle says it cooks it, what the 53 ingredients claim covers, and the date on that Keith Lee rating.
Emily Harper
A short clip making the rounds on Instagram says employees "leaked" what it calls Chipotle's "Play-Doh" steak: a vacuum-sealed bag packed with pink, soft-looking beef. The post that went with it adds three more claims. Chipotle markets 53 ingredients and no artificial additives, customers say the steak has gotten tough, dry and chewy, and Keith Lee, the food reviewer, dropped his steak quesadilla rating from a 10 to a 2.5.
Each of those is a different kind of claim, and some are older or narrower than the clip makes them sound. Here is what we could confirm, what we could not, and what is actually known about how Chipotle makes its steak.
What we could not confirm: the "leaked" clip
We could not trace the clip to a named employee, a restaurant or a date, and we found no news coverage of it. The footage shows a vacuum bag of meat in marinade. A sealed bag is consistent with how Chipotle says it cooks its beef, as described below, so the clip alone does not show something unusual. It looks like a step in a process the company has described itself, though we cannot say which step.
How Chipotle says it makes the steak
Chipotle's paper menu describes the steak as "responsibly raised, marinated in our chipotle adobo, then grilled". That leaves out a step. A report in The Takeout, syndicated on Yahoo, quotes Chipotle's website as saying it cooks the steak sous vide, "heating the beef at a precise, low temperature for a looong time," and then marinates it overnight in chipotle adobo. Tasting Table describes sous vide as cooking the meat in a water bath inside a vacuum-sealed bag, and says the steak is ready for the grill after the marinade.
The Takeout adds that Chipotle has acknowledged using sous vide to reduce food safety risk, moved to it in 2016 after a string of outbreaks, and cooks the meat at an off-site location. Those details come from that outlet, not from a Chipotle document we could read. It also notes that some customers complained after the switch that the beef tasted overcooked.
The official nutrition numbers are in Chipotle's paper menu. A 4-ounce serving of steak lists 150 calories, 6 grams of fat (2.5 saturated), 80 milligrams of cholesterol, 330 milligrams of sodium, 1 gram of carbohydrate and 21 grams of protein.
We tried to read Chipotle's full ingredient entry for the steak and could not load it in a form we could verify, so we are not printing an ingredient list here. Chipotle points readers to chipotle.com/ingredients for its ingredient details.
"53 ingredients, zero artificial additives": what the claim covers
Chipotle's 2017 announcement said it had no added colors, flavors or preservatives in any of the ingredients it uses to prepare food, with an exception for lemon and lime juice, and that it applied to its U.S. restaurants and did not include beverages. At that point it counted 51 ingredients. A May 2025 release refers to 53 real ingredients.
That is a claim about additives. It says nothing about whether the steak is tender, how big the portion is, or whether the oil it is cooked in is one you want to eat. A Tallow reviewer who checked Chipotle's published list found that every one of the 53 is a recognizable food, but that high-oleic sunflower oil appears in the chicken, white rice, beans and fajita vegetables. The review does not list the steak among them.
The Keith Lee rating is from May 2024
The 10-to-2.5 drop is real, but it is not new. Restaurant Business reported it on May 16, 2024, as part of a wave of complaints about shrinking portions. The steak quesadilla he had made famous fell in his rating, and he said "something changed." The article places that inside the portion-size complaints, not a steak-quality investigation. Chipotle's chief corporate affairs officer said in a statement that the company had "not changed our portion sizes."
By July 2024, then-CEO Brian Niccol said on an earnings call that about 10 percent of restaurants were outliers on portions and needed to be retrained, while saying there was never a directive to serve less. So the rating is a portion-size story from two years ago, and it was not about whether the steak is real.
Are customers still complaining about the steak?
Some are. A 2026 Yahoo roundup of customer complaints quotes one Reddit user who said that "mainly steak" quality had gotten so bad they could not finish a bowl because it was tough and dry. The same piece says there has been a steady stream of complaints about meat quality over the past year. That is anecdote and it comes from a handful of customers, not a lab test or a company statement. We found no 2026 statement from Chipotle responding to the steak complaints specifically.
What this adds up to
- Is the steak real beef? Chipotle describes it as beef, cooked sous vide, marinated in adobo and grilled. Nothing we found says otherwise.
- Does "Play-Doh" fit? The look of bagged, low-temperature-cooked meat can seem odd on camera. That is a texture and appearance observation. It is not evidence of a filler or an additive.
- Is it true Chipotle has no artificial additives? That is Chipotle's own claim, for U.S. restaurant food and not drinks. We did not test it.
- Has the steak gotten worse? That is a matter of opinion and reviews. The one claim in the post we could date was the Keith Lee rating, and it is from 2024.
Check what you are ordering
If the real question behind the clip is what you are eating at a chain, the label is the place to look, and for restaurants the label doesn't exist. Tallow scores restaurants on seed oils, additives, plastics and how processed the food is. Chipotle on Tallow scores 38 out of 100, pulled down mostly by seed oils on the hot line, while the guacamole, fresh salsas, cheese and sour cream are the clean exceptions. Scan packaged food or look up a restaurant before you order, and you can see what is behind the menu copy, not just the marketing line.